A Voice in the Wilderness In Defense of "Mere Conservatism"

7Oct/095

Students made to sing about health care

If you don't know why this video below is creepy, why making young children sing songs about the political policies of our president, then you are part of the problem.  Sorry, but you are.  You don't have to be, but you are.

Still don't think this is a big deal? Just close your eyes and imagine a public school teacher orchestrating a song-and-dance number for children to celebrate Bush's attempts to reform Social Security in 2005.  Then picture it on Fox News.

But you might be thinking that this is just one video, right?  It must be totally taken out of context and just the result of conservative, reactionary partisanship...

There is this:

And this classic:

And don't forget about the adults caught up in Obamania:

I love the memory of Ronald Reagan and what he accomplished and stood for.  Most conservatives do.  But we don't make music videos or build altars to the guy (other than the cardboard cut-out I have of his likeness in my room).  Conservatives don't write songs about their ideological leaders and presume that one man can change the world with the magic wave of his rhetorical wand (especially when that person has done NOTHING in his or her life before becoming president to garner such rabid allegiance).

We don't look to the government for our salvation.  That is at the heart of why these songs are even in existence: a firm belief that the only thing that has gone wrong for people has been George W. Bush and subsequently the only thing that can make everything alright is the election and reign of Good King Obama from the City of Wind.

Comments (5) Trackbacks (0)
  1. Hey, Robbie. I agree with and disagree with this post. The videos of children singing are a little offsetting. However! I remember reading somewhere that the choir was not mandatory, and the children had explicit permission from their parents to participate. If this is the case, I have not fault with their expression.

    As for ‘adults caught up in Obamania,’ I don’t find it shocking. At all. You must understand the weight of the occasion–and the extreme pride that many people (whites, black, and brown) have. Unlike Reagan, there were not 39 predecessor, color carbon copies before him. You make the mistake of comparing Obama, who is in his honeymoon stage, to the popularity of other presidents while we are still at the epicenter of the occasion’s greatness. Twenty years from now…things will not be the same. Of course.

    I would advise you to just bear it and wait it out. I feel that we forgot what it was like to have an extremely popular president.

  2. I echo Bradford’s thoughts…but I only agree with you RJ. I of course am happy to live in a country where a minority can reach the highest ranks of power…but what if that first one who does is found to be completely over-his-head and a firm believer in many things I couldnt disagree with more (i.e. abortion, wealth distribution, appeasement of our enemies, preposterous health care “reforms”, etc.)? Should I still be super excited because of his skin color? Isn’t that just reverse discrimination? Isn’t that just blind allegiance to melanin in your skin instead of the truth? I’m not trying to pick a fight Bradford, but if how would someone like you who supports President Obama respond to those questions?

    And one more thing…parents allowing their kids to sing anthems to a mortal man simply because of his skin color doesn’t make it any better in my opinion. Thanks for engaging me on this.

  3. I get where Bradford is coming from, and even thought I am white myself, I do appreciate the importance of the first black president. However, as Larry alluded to above, Martin Luther King’s dream was a country where men were judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin. I know quoting MLK doesn’t end the debate or anything, but if that is a standard by which all Americans should be judging one another, no skin color should be judging any other skin color (even their own….especially their own) by anything but the content of their character and their public actions.

  4. Hey Larry and Gilmore. In my opinion and observation, many people (including myself) see Obama as an embodiment of America as a country moving beyond partisanship, especially during such trying times as these: crazy deficit, two wars, financial collapse, foreclosures, etc. Do I, or many people, regard Obama as a messiah? Absolutely not! We were sold hope–and I think he’s delivering on some fronts. Even after he is gone, hopefully we can all retain this sentiment.

    This current climate is cause by how polarizing President Bush was. He had his fans, and he had many enemies. It’s a different climate when you have a newly elected president who many people desperately want to be the help America be the phoenix from the ashes.

    To answer you question, Larry, I don’t agree with a lot of things Obama has done/is doing. One of my biggest faults with him is his opinion on Abortion. But does that stop me from understanding and even being reverent of the circumstances of his election, the weight of the occasion? Naw… (note: I disagree with most of your examples. But not fight desired here).

    To the person who can’t understand the hype about color, just be respectful of others and the history of this great nation.

    my .02

  5. Let’s all just admit this is pretty creepy.

    The part I don’t get is when they talk about long lines… If they’re so worried about line-length, why would you want Obama’s healthcare plan? Line length will quadruple instantly.

    Smart lookin’ outfits. Not sure about the lyrics…


Leave a comment


No trackbacks yet.

What is “Mere Conservatism”?

The basic ideas, ideals, and values that generally define and characterize the central tenets of what today might be termed "modern conservative thought."

We believe that a proper understanding of history, economics, and theology leads to certain conclusions. Many of these are the same conclusions our Founding Fathers arrived at in constructing a "more perfect union."

All ideas and opinions are welcome; not all are correct.

Mere Conservatism Links:
 Econ Part I  |  Econ Part II
Intro  |  Theology  |  History

RJ Speaking at Acton 2010

Rudy the Dog barks at "change"

RJ's Social Network

Wall Street Journal

Blogroll

Columnists You Need to Read

News/Politics

Thinktanks

Archives

Categories

Historical Blogs

October 2009
M T W T F S S
« Sep   Nov »
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Meta

wordpress blog stats